Showing posts with label Raghuram Rajan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Raghuram Rajan. Show all posts

Friday, 9 March 2018

Why Banking Frauds Are So Frequent At PSU Banks

The terrain that is Indian banking turns tricky when government’s shareholder action in PSU banks starts impinging on RBI’s regulatory regime



It’s difficult not to detect a sense of déjà vu in the Nirav Modi scam, especially in all the hand-wringing and ex post facto zeal in setting up committees and investigations. Scams are a recurring motif in Indian banking, and the Punjab National Bank (PNB) case fits into the broad template of all previous stings.

In the search for solutions, a steady crescendo of drum-beats has been advocating whole-scale privatization of public sector (PSU) banks as a cure-all panacea. Implicit in the suggestion is the assumption that scams are the exclusive preserve of PSU banks. While it is true that the extent of scams and corruption is highest in PSU banks, data shows Indian private banks are not entirely immune.

The history of Indian banking over the past 50 years is littered with examples of failed private banks that were forcibly merged with stronger public sector banks (and with even stronger private banks recently—such as Bank of Rajasthan with ICICI Bank Ltd). This was done to safeguard depositors’ monies and to avoid systemic disruption. Here are a few random examples: Bank of Bihar was merged with State Bank of India in 1969; Hindustan Commercial Bank with PNB in 1986; Bari Doab Bank Ltd with Oriental Bank of Commerce in 1997; Kolkata-based United Industrial Bank merged with Allahabad Bank in 1989-90; Bank of Karad with Bank of India in 1994. The word merger has a volitional ring to it, but truth be told, there was nothing voluntary about these mergers.

Private banks have no special genes making them immune to scams and frauds. Global Trust Bank had to be merged with Oriental Bank of Commerce after its net worth was wiped out due to systemic fraud perpetrated by insiders. Even voluntary mergers in the post-reforms era are designed to escape distress and seek shelter with a stronger bank.

On balance, though, the larger proportion of scams in PSU banks does beg the question: why do they recur? One immediate reason could be the blurred lines of control and command. The government is the owner of PSU banks and exercises its shareholder rights capriciously: random appointments and transfers of chief executives, influencing appointment of board members, rationing out capital allocation in the name of fostering efficiency are some of the arbitrary control levers. The terrain turns tricky when government’s shareholder action starts impinging on Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI’s) regulatory regime. Bank senior executives, politically seasoned in picking up conflicting signals, reflexively align with the government even if it means contravening RBI’s regulatory framework.

For example, in the PNB fraud case, the bank’s core banking system (CBS) was not linked to its SWIFT system, thereby allowing officers to clandestinely issue letters of undertaking to Modi’s companies and confirming them with counter-party banks overseas through the SWIFT system.

This is despite RBI exhorting banks to link CBS with SWIFT; yet, PNB chose to violate these orders. It is, therefore, odd that none of the members of PNB’s governance troika—board, RBI or its all-powerful shareholder—pulled up the management or even sought an action taken report.

Former RBI governor Raghuram Rajan writes in his book, I Do What I Do: “Today, a variety of authorities…monitor the performance of public sector banks… It is important that we streamline and reduce the overlaps between the jurisdictions of the authorities, and specify clear triggers or situations where one authority’s oversight is invoked.”

RBI is tasked with detecting infirmities, but has no authority to enforce its own orders, administer remedial measures or even deliver swift punitive action. The central investigative agencies are tasked with following up on investigations and pursuing legal recourse. The political pulls and pressures on these agencies, as well as the Indian legal system’s long-drawn processes, provides swindlers with enough escape routes (pun intended), and is never a deterrent.

There is a likelihood that diminished incentives to regulate and supervise could be leading to weakened supervision and vigilance: most of it has become detection (after the event investigation) rather than prevention, which is to create systems and processes that raise alarms before the event or while transactions are taking place.

Flawed risk-mitigation design, which puts excessive focus on credit or market risks, has taken away attention from operation risk, leaving it susceptible to breaches. In addition, there is excessive dependence on manual supervision, at both external and internal levels. The sheer volume of transactions makes it impossible to manually control and supervise.

In the end, no matter what the design, somebody will always attempt to finesse the system. Blame corrupt politicians and bureaucrats, or the steadily disintegrating moral fibre of Indian businessmen, bankers and other white-collar professionals (as pointed out in this article), but scams are here to stay. The trick will be to construct a process design that prohibits anybody taking advantage of the system for sustained periods. And that will require dismantling some of the entitlement rights of the majority shareholder.

The above article was originally published in Mint newspaper and can also be read here

Wednesday, 31 May 2017

The Reserve Bank of India Is Changing Again

While RBI’s central board has certain powers, these have been rarely used to oppose finance ministry action


Time was when the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) resembled more a Soviet rationing officer than a conventional central bank. Mercifully, 1991 and economic reforms ended all that; the RBI got down to conventional central banking, which included moving the economy slowly out of administered interest rates, ending automatic monetization of government debt and shrinking its autarchic footprint. After a 26-year hiatus, there are misgivings that RBI could be lapsing into some of its old habits.

In the now defunct central banking format practised by RBI, all credit over Rs1 crore was rationed. Under a scheme called Credit Authorization Scheme, the RBI vetted all large loan proposals. Even though the floor was raised gradually over time, RBI continued to have a say in how much banks could lend to whom, and at what rate. The RBI was also the implementer (and custodian) of the government’s illiberal measures: banks had to compulsorily invest 40% of deposits in low-priced government securities and keep 20% with RBI as a cash reserve. Of the balance 40% left for lending, 40% had to be mandatorily lent at concessional rates, leaving “commercial” banks with only 24% of deposits to play around with. No wonder average lending rates ranged between 16-18% and non-performing assets were rarely recognized, leave alone provisioned.

These are now part of the nation’s sepia-tinted economic history. The RBI has been easing controls for the past 26 years, even though it has retained numerous other controls as part of its mandate to ensure monetary and financial stability. The overall process has not always been smooth or linear. Economic disruptions, both exogenous and endogenous, have occasionally forced the RBI to slow down or undertake course correction.

In recent months, there are suspicions that RBI’s reform mandate may have changed. The central bank’s role in the demonetization exercise sowed the first seeds of doubt. While the RBI’s central board has certain powers, these have been rarely used to oppose government action. Then, as well as now, the RBI would have gone along with the decision. But, here’s the crucial difference: governor and deputy governors could have used different platforms to speak their mind about the extreme decision. They would have made attempts to explain the economic shock to citizens. Instead, RBI’s March report on the macro-economic impact of demonetisation is an exercise in politesse.

Perhaps RBI doesn’t want to speak out because collateral damage from demonetisation has kept it incredibly busy.

Demonetization led to a liquidity surge, forcing the RBI to step in. Banks had no alternative route to deploy this liquidity, given the uncertainty created by demonetisation and industry’s non performing assets (NPA) induced aversion to bank credit. The RBI implemented a four-stage liquidity management programme, using different instruments at different times. Surplus liquidity also depressed debt yields. Around the same time, on 14 December, the US central bank Federal Reserve raised interest rates leading to outflow of foreign portfolio investment (FPI) from Indian debt markets—Rs46,087 crore went out during the last three months of 2016. This continued in January too. Consequently, the rupee-dollar exchange rate also mirrored these trends, depreciating initially and then staying range-bound for a month.

Then, suddenly around end-January, yields on the 10-year government bond started perking up. Foreign portfolio investment inflows also rushed in—Rs51,679 crore during February-April. By end-April, the rupee had also appreciated by almost 6.5% from the lows of 24 November.

The rupee’s appreciation has hurt exporters. But, more importantly, a 6.5% movement in such a short time is a sign of untreated volatility and should have been countered by the RBI. But, tackling the demonetization-led liquidity surge has probably left the RBI with little or no fire-power. Ordinarily, faced with such a predicament, the RBI would have used another weapon: talking the market down. But, neither the RBI governor nor his deputies has spoken a word over the past few months.

Two conclusions arise: either the RBI agrees with the current rupee value (which most economists think is over-valued) or it is scared to speak out. The government’s distaste for former RBI governor Raghuram Rajan’s public speeches was well publicized. RBI’s top brass has delivered only nine public speeches between January and May this year, compared with 23 last year.

Management of stressed assets is another example where the RBI seems to have abandoned characteristic central bank detachment. The RBI is stepping into the mud-pit of stressed assets to help banks recover sticky loans; this includes even taking commercial decisions regarding selection of credit rating agencies. This could expose RBI to serious risk, including reputational risk.

It might be instructive here to recall how Rajan spent his last days in office staving off pressure from the finance ministry, which insisted that the RBI use its balance-sheet to recapitalize public sector banks. At that time, deputy governor Viral Acharya (then professor with Stern School of Business) had criticized it in a Bloomberg story, saying, “At a minimum, it looks opaque and devious…could be perceived as an attack on central banking independence.”

At a time when globalization is in peril, the RBI seems to be voting for a dubious global trend: ceding autonomy to the political executive without a fight.

The above article was first published in Mont newspaper on May 31, 2017, and can also be read here

Wednesday, 5 April 2017

NPAs: The New Wedge in Centre-State Relations

NPAs are expected to acquire a two-tier, federal character with enormous implications for Centre-state relations

There was jubilation in stock markets recently after finance minister Arun Jaitley hinted at a scheme to sort out the messy tangle of bad loans in the banking sector. The equity market’s optimism beggars belief because NPAs—or non-performing assets, as bad loans are called technically—have remained impervious to an alphabet soup of previously attempted schemes. And now, NPAs are expected to acquire a two-tier, federal character with enormous implications for Centre-state relations.

In the post-1991 era, multiple schemes have been conceived and launched to tackle the menace of NPAs: DRTs (debt recovery tribunals, as suggested by Narasimham Committee-I and then subsequently amended in 2012), CDR (corporate debt restructuring), SARFAESI Act (Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest), CRILC and JLF (Central Repository of Information on Large Credits and Joint Lenders’ Forum), 5/25 scheme, ARC restructuring (asset reconstruction companies, formed as a consequence of DRTs), SDR (strategic debt restructuring), AQR (asset quality review), S4A (scheme for sustainable structuring of stressed assets) and finally the IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code).

There are multiple reasons for many of these schemes failing, which includes an inadequate legal framework for pursuing resolution; however, the one reason that remains unchanged from pre-reforms period is final policy design always providing corporate borrowers enough protection so that they can reprise the same act all over again. And while public attention has focused on Vijay Mallya—deservedly of course—there are other larger industrial groups which are habitual offenders but manage the system adroitly. Former Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governor Raghuram Rajan was compelled to state: “…it is extremely important that banks do not use the new flexible schemes for promoters who habitually misuse the system (everyone knows who these are) or for fraudsters.”

This raises issues of “moral hazard”; in the Indian context, moral hazard has taken the form of corporates or public sector banks undertaking increasingly riskier behaviour because they know the government is underwriting that risk or bearing the cost of that risk. Post the 2008 financial crisis, moral hazard has acquired some flexibility globally: it has become acceptable to bail out institutions if government feels such failure can lead to widespread systemic risk.

This may have inspired finance ministry’s chief economic advisor Arvind Subramanian to blithely suggest that government should perhaps bail out large corporate borrowers because that is how “capitalism works”. He feels only write-offs can sort out the “mountain of debt” sitting on bank books, or settle the twin-balance sheet problem (over-leveraged companies and NPA burdened banks). 

Interestingly, Subramanian has also contributed to the NPA soup cauldron: the annual economic survey recommends the creation of PARA, or Public Sector Asset Rehabilitation Agency. Not to be left behind, even RBI’s recently appointed deputy governor Viral Acharya has gamely added his two-bit: PAMC (Private Asset Management Company) and NAMC (National Asset Management Company).

So, while attempts are being made to untangle the knotted skein of corporate bad loans, albeit through an ever-growing thicket of acronyms, Jaitley has at the same time flatly turned down requests for farm loan waivers. He has received wide support. State Bank of India chairman Arundhati Bhattacharya has warned that fulfilling such pre-election promises might lead to dilution of credit discipline: borrowers might tend to defer repayment till the next elections in the hope of loan waivers. This newspaper also recently pointed out that the Indian agricultural sector needs long-term structural investments, not short-term exchequer-funded loan waivers. There is merit in each of these arguments.

But, here’s a catch: the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party also promised farm loan waivers in its Uttar Pradesh assembly election manifesto. Having won the elections and faced with the prospect of fulfilling that promise now, Jaitley has used an escape hatch to wriggle out of the commitments. Answering the debate on Finance Bill in Rajya Sabha, he has asked individual states to foot the bill for farm loan waivers. He has effectively created a two-tier, federal, moral hazard framework: Centre’s responsibility to bail out large corporates and states get to write off farm loans.

This further complicates attempts at creating a long-term, sustainable set of solutions for controlling and resolving the financial system’s NPAs. It also adds new headaches to the already vexed Centre-state relations. Competitive waiver promises have already weakened the fragile balance sheets of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. 

It also raises issues of discrimination. If the Centre wants to bail out some 30-40 large corporate borrowers on the pretext that their debt misery was the outcome of external shocks, does not the same logic or argument apply to farm loans, especially since many states have been victims of droughts, inadequate monsoons and crop failures? There is no doubt the NPA mess needs to be resolved urgently to kick-start investments and the growth process. But then, that solutions framework cannot be built on the foundation of discrimination and selective relief.

The above article was published in Mint newspaper and can also be read here

Sunday, 15 January 2017

The world’s strongmen are eroding the autonomy of central banks. Exhibit A: India

Whatever the differences over the demonetisation fallout, there is near consensus over one collateral damage: the reputation of the country’s central bank, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), has taken a severe beating after 86% of the country’s currency (by value) was withdrawn and not replaced on time. But, worse, there is a growing perception that the central bank buckled under government pressure and rubber-stamped demonetisation. Fingers are pointing at governor Urjit Patel for readily agreeing; this may be jumping to conclusions but governor Patel’s non-communicative mien has not helped matters.

Three former RBI governors have publicly lamented the erosion of the central bank’s relative autonomy. Former governor Y V Reddy expressed concern about the knocks the RBI is taking: “For the RBI, for a central bank, reputational risk is the worst risk…And if this is happening in the international opinion, I would say that it is a national problem now and it is not just a political issue.” Even Reddy’s predecessor, Bimal Jalan, chimed in with his concerns over threats to the RBI’s autonomy. The opening line of former deputy governor Usha Thorat’s recent op-ed was anguish-laden: “It is indeed a sad day to see one of the most respected public institutions in India becoming an object of ridicule and scorn.”

India is only playing catch-up


On closer scrutiny, though, this shouldn’t come as a surprise. India is only following a global trend. The world over, in countries with right-wing governments headed by perceived “strongmen,” the executive has locked horns with serving central bank governors, and in some cases even abrogated the relative autonomy of the central bank. India is only playing catch-up: the refusal to extend former governor Raghuram Rajan’s term, and the growing public perception of Patel’s inability to dissent, further reinforces the notion of India tacking on to a global trend.

Two recent examples testify to the global pattern’s prevalence. President-elect Donald Trump denounced US Federal Reserve chief Janet Yellen on his campaign trail, claiming she was playing politics with interest rates (translation: she was keeping interest rates deliberately low to help Hillary Clinton) and should be replaced. Whether he will follow through on that promise will be known only after Jan. 18.

In England, soon after securing the referendum supporting Brexit, Conservative Party grandees—notably Michael Gove and former foreign secretary William Hague—tore into Bank of England (BoE) governor Mark Carney. They were taking their cue from prime minister Theresa May who, at an earlier party conference, had slammed the BoE for the low interest rates and quantitative easing since it short-changed savers. Carney has since dropped dark hints of resigning.

The relationship between elected politicians and central bankers has always been fraught. The 2008 trans-Atlantic financial crisis has deepened the chasm with central banks being increasingly asked to take on quasi-fiscal responsibilities. This has resulted in increasing institutional friction.

In Japan, soon after prime minister Shinzo Abe assumed office in December 2012, he leaned on the Bank of Japan (BoJ) to print more money and to bump up its inflation target from 1% to 2%; both measures would require the BoJ to pursue an expansionary monetary policy. This, the government hoped, would provide the necessary growth stimulus to the economy and finally help Japan escape the pernicious deflationary trap that’s plagued the economy for over 10 years. BoJ governor Masaaki Shirakawa was initially reluctant and when the pressure continued to pile on, he resigned in February 2013, two months before he was due to retire.

The Hungarian president and head of the right-wing party Fidesz, Viktor Orban (who recently built barbed wire fences to keep out immigrants), used his majority powers in parliament to browbeat the central bank into submission. He even went to the extent of replacing the sitting governor with long-time Fidesz politician Gyorgy Matolcsy. Interestingly, Matolcsy currently faces myriad allegations of cronyism and misuse of public funds, including those of the central bank to window-dress the government’s fiscal health.

Closer home, Sri Lanka has been witnessing heightened tensions between central bank governor Indrajit Coomaraswamy and finance minister Ravi Karunanayake.

More than just monetary policy


Bank of Israel governor Stanley Fischer resigned ahead of his retirement date, sparking off rumours of differences with prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Fischer subsequently joined the Federal Reserve as vice-chairman. A year ago, he had delivered a speech on central bank independence, in which he made an interesting point, one that resonates with the Indian situation. He said: “…there is a distinction between the terms monetary policy independence and central bank independence. In the literature that developed before the global financial crisis, central bank independence referred to independence from political influences in the setting of monetary policy. But many central banks have roles outside monetary policy—in particular, bank regulation and supervision. These roles are in certain cases granted their own level of independence…”

This point has also been made by former governor Y V Reddy: “There are two types of confusion… my own suspicion is that the institutional identity of the RBI has been damaged… the RBI is the monetary authority, yes. But it is also a full-service central bank. It is in charge of many other things. The recent emphasis appeared as though monetary policy is the main function. The governor is accountable to monetary policy. Then he is not accountable to regulation, he is not accountable to currency coins? There is a confusion about relative importance. That relative importance is being decided more outside than within.”

Successive governments have found ways of corroding each of these different independent roles. For instance, under the previous Congress-led government, former finance minister Pranab Mukherjee (currently the country’s president) set up in 2013 a new financial sector monitoring body, called Financial Stability and Development Council, to be chaired by the finance minister. This was a clear intrusion; the central bank’s mandate includes financial stability. The RBI governor was put on par with other regulators, which betrays a flawed understanding of a central bank’s role and remit.

The Australian example is instructive. The governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia chairs the single integrated prudential regulator, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, as well as the Council of Financial Regulators.

Rule by fiat


The process of emasculating the RBI seems to have accelerated now. The surgical changes to RBI’s governance structure are telling: The government’s unwillingness to fill up vacant posts of independent directors is believed to have accelerated the passage of the demonetisation proposal and helped obtain the central bank’s acquiescence overnight. Ordinarily, the central bank would have debated and dissented, after assessing the logistical nightmare of not only distributing fresh cash to the wide network of bank branches across the country but also recalibrating and replenishing over 200,000 ATMs across the country.

Subsequent RBI submissions to parliament’s committee on finance disclosed that the central bank had acted on government advice.

Truth be told, the RBI Act does not empower the central bank with absolute autonomy, but the RBI does have relative autonomy allowing it to pursue certain monetary and regulatory functions with some degree of independence, free from political pressure. Saying “no” in the interest of avoiding short-term volatility and ensuring the economy’s long-term health is part of the job. Tinkering with this fine balance will have massive repercussions, including undermining investor confidence in various asset markets.

The article first appeared in www.qz.com on January 15, 2017, and can also be read read here

Monday, 20 June 2016

The Legacy: Raghuram Rajan is leaving the battlefield just when he was getting the better of his rivals

India’s debonair central banker, Raghuram Rajan, leaves behind many broken hearts and disappointed souls. Chronicles of his legacy will list many achievements, but will also note that he left the battlefield just when he was getting the better of his rivals; what’s surprising is that the commander-in-chief agreed to his pre-mature withdrawal even though the general’s strategies could be seen bearing fruit.

Equally perplexing will be the choice of his replacement.

Both the government and Rajan personally have been advocates of an alternative global financial architecture. He has also been proposing for a while that it was time for a new Bretton Woods mechanism. And Rajan had taken the battle to the enemy camp. At the April 2016 spring meetings of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, Rajan observed how deeply multilateral financial institutions were in thrall of western economic orthodoxies. He even wryly remarked how ideas from emerging economies were dismissed as “crankiness.”

He was prescient about the trans-Atlantic financial crisis. He took on former US Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke when US domestic monetary policy spilled over into the global economy and led to severe volatility in emerging markets. He is unlikely to have fond memories of the period: he had to douse this particular fire soon after his appointment in Sept. 2013.

So, here is question number one: Will his successor have the same zeal about promoting an alternative global financial architecture that is sensitive to emerging economy needs and is not partisan about any particular economic ideology?

Rajan also quits before another crusade could be brought to its logical end. He’s been battening down the hatches that allowed a cosy nexus between large corporate borrowers, bankers, politicians, and bureaucrats, to bleed public sector banks through questionable debt write-offs. Rajan had taken a large broom to bank balance sheets and forced them to take drastic action against defaulters.

Many large—and over-stretched—corporate borrowers have been carping about Rajan’s reluctance to reduce interest rates, which, when lowered, would have certainly helped moderate their interest burden. These same corporates also turned into quack economists on the matter of interest rates: in their collective view, only lower interest rates could bring back high rates of economic growth. This view is oblivious to the fact that the low interest rates in the US, or negative rates in Europe and Japan, have failed to promote any economic growth.

Time for question number two: Will Rajan’s successor have the stomach (or benign sanction from the government) to continue with the clean-up act? Or to hold rates steady when required?

So, what does Rajan’s legacy look like? Apart from the well-documented success in fending off volatility from the US Fed’s tapering in 2013, his tenure will be remembered for three systemic changes he fostered.

One will be the differentiated banking landscape that he designed and left behind. As RBI governor, he grandfathered the emergence of a new breed of universal, small, and payments banks. He was in the process of adding two more categories—custodian banks and wholesale (or long-term) financing banks—to the mix. We will now have to wait and see if his successor has the same enthusiasm for a differentiated banking model.

These new categories come in addition to existing myriad forms of cooperative banks, regional rural banks, local area banks, public sector scheduled commercial banks, State Bank of India group of scheduled commercial banks, old-generation private sector banks, new-generation private sector banks, and foreign banks.

Restive signs mark the payments banks space—three companies which received in-principle approval to launch payments banks (Cholamandalam, Tech Mahindra, and Dilip Shanghvi of Sun Pharma) returned their licences stating that the project was not economically feasible. Undeniably, and in true RBI style, the initial architecture is anti-profit and has flaws in it.

The second marquee item is his strict action against non-performing assets (NPAs) that continue to impair bank balance-sheets. This was viewed as his struggle to end Indian-style crony capitalism: large volumes of loans remain unpaid every year and yet defaulting borrowers manage to get fresh loans unfailingly with some help from politicians, bureaucrats, and complicit bankers.

The staggering amount of NPAs is a direct drain on taxpayers, since loss to state-owned bank balance sheets must be compensated with fresh equity infusion by the largest shareholder—government— every year.

Finally, the outgoing governor will be remembered for installing a new monetary policy framework, which uses inflation-targeting as its driving philosophy. It also includes a monetary policy committee comprising three government representatives and three central bankers, with the RBI governor getting the casting vote. This new structure overhauls the old belief that the economy’s fiscal (the government) and monetary policy (central bank) sides should remain out of each other’s hair.

While the government has been uncomfortable with Rajan’s public comments about governance and broader political economy trends—saying that central bankers should not interfere with the fiscal side—it has not shown the same restraint when trying to influence monetary policy.

It will have to be seen how future central bankers and monetary historians view Rajan’s acquiescence to large government presence in monetary policy making.

The article first appeared in www.qz.com/india and can also be read here.

Thursday, 24 September 2015

Don't Bank On It

Decoding Raghuram Rajan's antipathy towards industrial conglomerates.


Finally, India is on its way to hosting a differentiated set of banks, each of which will perform a set of pre-determined functions. Central bank Reserve Bank of India (RBI) granted in-principle approval on September 16 to 10 entities for launching a "small bank". In August, it approved 11 institutions for activating "payments banks". In 2014, RBI had granted approval to two private sector organisations for launching "universal banks".

These "in-principle" approvals will be converted into licences after 18 months from grant of approval once the regulator is satisfied that the institution has met all conditions.

So far, so good. But a few issues need clarity.

One, different bank categories already exist in the system — cooperative banks (there are five kinds under this head), local area banks and regional rural banks. Add to that the universal banks which can broadly be slotted under four heads, according to ownership — State Bank of India and its associate banks, public sector banks, old generation private banks, new generation private banks and, finally, foreign banks. So, while competition is good, is it still unclear how the new banks will make any dent.

Let me explain.

Let's start with the payments banks. According to RBI's guidelines, these banks can only accept deposits, provide remittance services, issue ATM/debit cards (not credit cards), act as a business correspondent of another universal bank, distribute third-party investment products (another company's mutual fund, insurance or pension fund products), among other things. But there's one big difference: payments banks cannot lend. On top of which, they have to invest 75 per cent of their deposits in government securities or treasury bills with a maximum maturity of one year, and the balance 25 per cent in fixed deposits or current account of another scheduled commercial bank.

This brings us to the second point: The pathway to a respectable rate of return for payments banks seems ridden with multiple potholes. As per the guidelines, payments banks have four key areas of business opportunity, all of which yield fee-based incomes: fee from remittances, fee from transaction services (such as debit cards), fees from sale of third party investment products, fees for providing business correspondent services.

But given the capital cost, the network roll-out expenses and the cost of managing operational risks, this revenue source might not be enough to provide adequate returns. Or, the volumes that will be required to generate adequate returns might be difficult to achieve. Plus, given the demographic profile of a payments bank's core constituency, ticket sizes are likely to be small and perhaps misaligned with acquisition costs. This is despite use of technology solutions to lower costs.

On top of this, the payments bank will have some genuine dilemmas. One, how does it price deposits? If it's lower than universal banks, it could raise issues of discrimination. Also, if it has to make a spread from investing in gilts, then deposit rates have to be lower than the sovereign yield rates. Will anybody bite at these rates? It will, therefore, have to rely on high-yield fees, such as those paid on sale of insurance or pension products. Some kind of regulatory framework might be necessary here, given the scope for mis-selling.

The telecom operators, though, may have a slight edge. They might be in a position to leverage their network and customer base for remittances and other related services. This not only lowers their acquisition costs immediately but also obviates the need for brick-and-mortar network substantially.

That might explain why Aditya Birla Nuvo (Idea Telecom), Reliance Industries Ltd (Jio), Airtel M Commerce Services Ltd and Vodafone m-pesa Ltd have got an approval for launching payments banks. The other interesting candidate is individual Vijay Shekhar Sharma, who started popular mobile wallet company Paytm. Aditya Birla Nuvo is the holding company for the AV Birla Group's financial and telecom services. Reliance, on the other hand, has tied up with India's largest bank State Bank of India, apart from launching its nation-wide 4G telecom network Jio.

Many large corporates had earlier expressed a desire to obtain universal banking licences, but were quietly discouraged by RBI. Many large business houses owned banks pre-nationalisation and, for some of them, obtaining a banking licence is like re-acquiring a business that was snatched away. But, the payments bank guidelines do not spell out a clear migration path to universal banking.

On the other hand, the guidelines for small banks do have a clear transition route, which includes a five-year track record as a small bank. But, here's the rub: the guidelines also say, "…proposals from large public sector entities and industrial and business houses, including from NBFCs promoted by them, will not be entertained."

So, this is the third leg of RBI's bank licensing process: keeping corporates out of banking, specifically the lending business, through an elaborate route.

RBI allows small banks to migrate to universal banks, but precludes industry houses from applying for small banks. It lets corporates apply for payments banks, but locks the door leading to universal banking. Even among payment bank applicants, companies or industrial groups which did not have a clear advantage in payments banking — such as Kalpataru Corporation or Videocon d2h Ltd — were not considered.

In its press release announcing names of successful applicants for small banks, RBI stated: "…the Reserve Bank intends to use the learning from this licensing round to appropriately revise the Guidelines and move to giving licences more regularly, that is, virtually 'on tap'." It's still unclear whether on-tap licensing is only for small banks or will be extended to universal banks also, and whether there will be some thawing in RBI's antipathy towards industrial conglomerates.

We might have to first wait for the NPA tide to ebb before RBI warms up to the idea of banks launched by industrial houses.

Originally published in Outlook magazine (http://www.outlookindia.com/article/dont-bank-on-it/295433#comments) under column "Man About Mumbai"  

Saturday, 1 August 2015

Busting Myths Around Raghuram Rajan's RBI

There is no definitive proof that lower interest rates will lead unquestionably to higher economic growth.

The revised Indian Financial Code, put in the public domain by Finance Ministry, has divided economists, observers and experts into two distinct, sharply-delineated camps. On one side are those who are desperate to clip the Reserve Bank governor’s wings, and on the other are those who want his unspoken, uncovenanted autonomy to remain untouched, uncompromised. 

In the midst of this brouhaha, discussions about reforming the central bank’s governance framework has fallen through the cracks. While the debate about reducing the Governor’s powers rages endlessly, there is little attention being paid to what happens even after the change is effected. The Governor will still be answerable only to Finance Minister, and not to Parliament or a select committee of Parliament, as is the practice in many countries and as it should be in India too. It is surprising that this aspect of central bank reforms has failed to merit any discussion.

The revised code, among other things, has suggested that monetary policy, the exclusive preserve of central banks all over the world, should be decided by a monetary policy committee. Today, the final decision vests with the governor who, after consulting multiple bodies and committees, then has the sole discretionary power to take any monetary action. It is the composition of this recommended committee that has got people worked up. According to the revised code, the committee should have the RBI governor in the chair, two more RBI employees and four “persons appointed by the Central Governor”. Moreover, each member will have one vote and decisions will be taken on the basis of majority vote. 

With four votes, the government’s nominees immediately constitute a majority. Even more sinister is Article 257 in the code, which enjoins the Central government to nominate one representative to the meeting. This representative will not have a vote but will participate in the committee’s deliberations and will read out a statement from the government at the meeting. The import of this is not lost: with a representative watching the proceedings and delivering the central government’s message at the meeting, will any government nominee dare go against New Delhi’s wishes?

Arguments have been made that, in a democracy, the executive should have some say over a critical economic function like monetary policy. There is a basic flaw with this argument; separation of powers is a fundamental tenet of democracy, especially where the government’s actions can have an abiding impact on people’s lives. The inflationary stickiness arising from the 2008-09 stimulus programme is still haunting the Indian economy. Unlike the thick, Constitutional boundary separating the legislature from the judiciary, the line segregating the executive and the central bank is thin and rooted more in convention and common economic sense. 

It has become fashionable for economists of a certain orientation to demand reduced powers for the central bank governor. There are a couple of problems with that. First, under the new contract signed between RBI and the government, RBI is responsible for ensuring that consumer inflation remains within a pre-determined band. If the Governor ’s powers to use monetary tools to achieve that objective are taken away, then it somehow nullifies the inflation contract.

Second, the Indian economy has always been marked by fiscal dominance, which has been cogently explained by Niranjan Rajadhyaksha (http://goo.gl/3uwpz4) in his column for newspaper Mint. In simple words, monetary policy in India has always followed fiscal policy. The government’s fiscal policy, resulting in fiscal deficits, has forced the central bank to fashion monetary policy with the objective of tackling the after-effects of fiscal excesses. The RBI has worked hard over the past 25 years to minimise the deleterious impact of government’s profligacy on monetary policy. The government, in seeking to control both fiscal and monetary policies now, will negate all that has been achieved in stabilising the economy.

At the heart of the demand to shift the reins of monetary policy is a popular myth: reducing interest rates will automatically stimulate economic growth. Like all myths, especially those relating to flying machines of antiquity, there is no definitive scientific — or statistical — proof that lower interest rates will lead unquestionably to higher economic growth. Interestingly, another prevalent myth about the Indian economy being “decoupled” from the global economy evaporated quite rapidly after 2009. 

Many economists and industry lobbies have been incensed by RBI’s refusal to lower interest rates. Former RBI governor D Subbarao raised interest rates 13 times in quick succession. It was hoped his successor, Raghuram Rajan, would be divorced from such “anti-growth” orthodoxies. And, even though he has lowered interest rates, the pace has not been found too satisfactory. 

Beyond myths, a softer interest rate regime definitely has some side benefits: lower interest rates will automatically reduce the debt servicing burden of many large corporates which have borrowed way beyond their digestive capacities. While the RBI has been critical about the mounting levels of sticky loans in bank books and the behavioural patterns displayed by corporate borrowers, the government believes the investment cycle — especially “Make In India” — will not revive unless this staggering debt mass is sorted out.

Finally, the revised code employs some rather curious appellations: for example, it keeps referring to the RBI governor as “chairperson”. For example, Article 256(2)(a) says the monetary policy committee will comprise “the Reserve Bank Chairperson as its chairperson”. Last time I checked, RBI had no chairperson. He doesn’t exist even in the RBI Act.

Courtesy Outlook magazine: http://goo.gl/V1IALu 

Thursday, 19 March 2015

IMF And RBI — Lost In Transmission

The IMF’s 2014 review has some good GDP news but its reservations on interest rates bears closer attention. It can take 32 months for the effects of a an interest rate cut to be felt. What does this mean for the Indian economy?


Christine Lagarde International Monetary Fund (IMF) Managing Director was in India on 16 March for a two-day trip following the 11 March release of the IMF’s 2014 annual review of the Indian economy. The review has some good GDP news for India. Predictably, everybody focused mostly on the growth forecast for 2014-15 and for 2015-16 and (expectedly) missed out IMF’s reservations on a key ingredient that facilitates growth in any economy — interest rates.

There’s a bit of a story behind the IMF’s salubrious growth forecast. The original set of two IMF documents (in which Indian GDP was initially estimated to grow by 6.3% in 2014-15 and by 6.5% in 2015-16) had to be supplemented by two additional reports — one a transcript of the discussion between IMF officials and media, and, two, a copy of the IMF Survey which updated India’s growth forecast, in line with the government’s new methodology. Consequently, IMF now expects India’s GDP to grow by 7.2% during fiscal 2014-15 and by 7.5% during 2015-16.

Growth junkies celebrated this international endorsement for India’s growth prospects. They have been hankering for a rate cut, arguing that the only thing standing between them and double-digit annual growth rates were intractably high interest rates. The Reserve Bank (RBI) has rewarded them with two rate cuts — one in January and another in early March, soon after announcement of Budget. There are now demands for more, and deeper, rate cuts.

But, if they had read the IMF report a bit more closely, they might have been disappointed. The source of frustration is an accompanying document released with the India country report — called Selected Issues (as background documentation) — which includes a chapter on monetary transmission. On the basis of an internal model, this document reckons that the two-stage transmission between a repo rate cut to bank lending rate cut, via the weighted average call money rate, takes a total of 32 months. The impact on deposit rates is faster at 23 months.

Translated, that means RBI’s repo rate cut in January 2015 is likely to result in lower bank lending rates only by September 2017. The final impact on economic output and price levels, and hence growth impetus, will take even longer to feed through the relevant economic linkages. While that does seem a bit extreme, there is no denying that there is a large, looming problem in the room that nobody wants to acknowledge: transmission problems, or crimps in the financial pipeline.

RBI’s rate actions tend to take ages to travel through the economic system before they translate into lower borrowing rates for firms and households at the other end. In short, the transmission time between RBI’s rate action and banks cutting their lending rates is inordinately long, fraught with uncertainties and resistant to any mapping or measurement. Hence, nobody knows — with any modicum of certainty — how exactly this decision travels through the system, or how long this entire process will take.

The IMF report also refutes RBI’s estimates regarding transmission time, as well as dents the central bank’s confidence of improving lags and lead times under the new monetary arrangement it has signed with the Centre. The Urjit Patel Committee had mentioned that “…monetary policy in India impacts output with a lag of about 2-3 quarters and WPI headline inflation with a lag of about 3-4 quarters and the impact persists for 8-12 quarters.”

RBI has on numerous occasions — through working papers, speeches, media interactions and committee reports — acknowledged the problem of transmission leads and lags in India’s monetary policy. Most reports agree that transmission in India works through a number of channels — interest rate, credit markets, foreign exchange rates, asset prices (such as equity or house prices), expectations (about future shocks and belief in central bank ability to counter adversity) — with the existing fiscal and monetary system acting as final arbiters of the speed of transmission.

In each of the channels mentioned above, there are speed-breakers that slow down the pace of transmission. In the interest rate channel, for example, the existence of a large informal sector with largely inelastic borrowing rates, or high interest rates charged in the microfinance sector, impede transmission of rate cuts to output and inflation. Take government borrowing. Not only does it artificially dampen interest rates, it also forcibly appropriates a fixed amount of the banking system’s lendable funds, providing banks with a disincentive to heed market signals. This is one of the things that make it difficult for an RBI repo cut to materialise as a bank lending rate cut.

The Indian financial sector is dominated by banks, with public sector bank providing the bulk of banking services. The unusually large presence of state-owned banks

Hence, in the face of the conflicting transmission time periods provided by IMF and RBI, as well as the existence of innumerable structural road bumps that hinder smooth diffusion of monetary policy, there are legitimate questions about the efficacy of the monetary policy arrangement between RBI and the government.

Kind courtesy Gateway House (here) and Hindu BusinessLine (here)

Monday, 9 March 2015

A Sharing of Instruments

RBI’s new brief to curb inflation comes with a cut in its independence

Like many other things, the Reserve Bank of India has come late to the party. And it has celebrated with a rate cut. Announced on Wednesday morning, outside its usual, scheduled policy review cycle, the RBI cut the benchmark rate by 25 basis points. This is questionable.

What’s curious is the timing: it seems to indicate that the RBI is returning a favour to the government for having signed the monetary policy framework agreement. Signed between the RBI and the Union finance ministry on February 20, it enjoins the RBI to bring inflation—as measured by consumer price index (CPI)—below 6 per cent by January 2016, and thereafter strive to keep it at 4 per cent (with an error margin of plus/minus 2 per cent). Any deviation will be considered a failing, requiring an explana­tion.

The monetary policy framework with a single nominal anchor was recommended by an RBI-constituted expert committee and chaired by RBI deputy governor Urjit Patel. The choice of CPI (combined) as nominal anchor is also in keeping with similar recommendations made by earlier committees, such as the Raghuram Rajan committee and the Percy Mistry committee. It would thus seem that a chorus of orchestrated voices, seemingly with an aligned ideological perspective, has managed to refashion the RBI’s role and purpose.

What is disquieting is the way it tilts at independent monetary policy. The decision also comes at a time when there is an attempt to steadily erode the RBI’s independence (however limited), either through curtailing its powers or through unilateral transfer to the executive, as evident in this budget.

The first is a move to amend Section 6 of Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), which empowers the RBI to control foreign exchange flows. Arun Jaitley stated in his budget speech: “Capital account controls is a policy, rather than a regulatory, matter. I, therefore, propose to amend, through the Finance Bill, Section-6 of FEMA to clearly provide that control on capital flows as equity will be exercised by the government, in consultation with the RBI.” The immediate provocation for this is believed to be an embittered separation process between a leading Indian conglomerate and a foreign telco; to make matters worse, RBI rules on put options in share agreements delayed a settlement. Eventually, though, the RBI is believed to have made exceptions to its rules for this deal.

The second is the setting up of a public debt management agency “which will bring both India’s external borrowings and domestic debt under one roof”, which are all under the RBI’s watch currently. There is also no clarity on the nature of the agency—will it be independent, will it be under the finance ministry or quasi-autonomous? This clarification is necessary because a debt management agency should be in a position to either influence interest rates or take the punch-bowl away in times of excessive fiscal expansion.

In the aftermath of the RBI’s war-mode attack on inflation and inflationary expectations, influential voices have been demanding that its powers be curtailed or stripped. Many blamed the RBI, wrongly of course, for the current economic slowdown. This is not peculiar to India. With a prolonged global slowdown prompting countries to elect conservative candidates, central banks have felt the heat in Israel, Japan and Hungary.

The decision to forge a new monetary policy agreement, especially when aca­d­emics are questioning inflation targeting, has some unexplained areas. First, the RBI has no control over half the constituents in the rebased CPI index (food or fuel items), so this raises questions about influence monetary policy action can have on price behaviour. Second, the RBI has complained in the past about the quality of data collection and analysis, but is willing to submit itself to be judged by the same touchstone. Three, there is an undeniable, but com­­plicated relationship between employment and inflation. The latest economic survey highlights the dis­tortions in une­mployment data; this compact is then bui­lding a framework using the bedrock of two publicly ackn­owledged noisy databases. Four, the transmission route and the time-lag bet­ween monetary policy action and its impact on the price line is unclear; the RBI’s brave promise the­refore to hold down the price line to a specific number using monetary policy is surprising.

The final picture will emerge when monetary policy committee members are selected. One hopes they will be independent professionals, selected not for their political beliefs but their understanding of monetary economics. Finally, one also hopes that the RBI governor will get to have the last word on that committee.

Reprinted with permission from Outlook Magazine: 
http://www.outlookindia.com/article/A-Sharing-Of-Instruments/293613
and, 
Gateway House: http://www.gatewayhouse.in/a-sharing-of-instruments-2/

Thursday, 12 February 2015

A Tobin Tax For India

In its recent monetary policy document, the Reserve Bank of India has imposed strict maturity conditions on foreign portfolio investment in debt to get a better handle on risk. But a fiscal solution would be more elegant and effective

The nervousness is back, and so are direct physical controls. In an otherwise staid monetary policy document released on 3 February 2015, Reserve Bank of India governor Raghuram Rajan has inserted one small restriction: henceforth all foreign portfolio investors investing in debt instruments—issued by government or private sector companies—have to hold on to their investments for a minimum of three years.

The policy decision is a discreet admission of the risks confronting the Indian economy, as well as a hint of the Indian central bank’s anxieties.

But imposing administrative controls in this day and age—even if they are meant to mitigate risks—sends wrong signals, especially when alternative fiscal instruments are available to achieve the same results. Even the European Union has agreed to implement such a measure despite stiff opposition from Britain and Sweden: the magic bullet is called a Tobin tax.

India must also consider introducing such a tax With Finance Minister Arun Jaitley searching for newer sources of revenue, Budget 2015-16 (to be announced on February 28) will be the right vehicle for announcing this levy.

Named after American economist and Nobel laureate James Tobin, the tax is levied on financial transactions and is aimed at curbing speculation and volatility. Although the tax was originally proposed by Tobin in the 1970s for a post-Bretton Woods global financial system—to curb short-term currency speculation and its attendant risks to the economy (through high interest rates)—over time it has come to denote taxes on all kinds of financial transactions, with each country re-interpreting the concept in its own unique manner. For example, Italy imposed a variation of the tax on high frequency share trading in September 2013—a 0.02% tax on trades occurring every 0.5 seconds or faster. [1]

After years of discussions and dissent, 11 European countries—Belgium, Germany, Estonia, Greece, Spain, France, Italy, Austria, Portugal, Slovenia and Slovakia—have also decided to introduce a financial transactions tax from 1 January 2016. [2] Under the finalised proposal, the 11 countries will impose a 0.1% levy on exchange of shares and bonds, and a 0.01% impost on derivative transactions.

However, Britain and Sweden have already voiced their dissent to the proposal and are likely to oppose its enactment. It is also not known whether Italy will continue with the tax on high-frequency trading after 2016.

The Tobin tax approach has been tried in other countries as well—such as Thailand, Brazil, Chile, and Malaysia—with mixed results. However, in Brazil and Malaysia (and, to some extent, in Chile) the tax is said to have achieved the desired results of curbing volatile short-term currency flows.

India already has a form of Tobin tax in place—the Securities Transaction Tax (STT). Introduced in 2004, the STT is levied on every transaction of securities listed on the stock exchanges and mutual funds. According to Budget documents, the STT helped net Rs. 5,497 crores revenue for the government during 2013-14. [3] The estimate for 2014-15 is Rs. 5,991 crores.

A Tobin tax could be levied on foreign portfolio investors who decide to cash out their investments in Indian bonds before a certain period. This has dual benefits—the investments stay for a longer and predictable period (thereby insulating the economy from egregious volatility), and earn additional revenue for the government as well.

This might be much more elegant than what the RBI is proposing. The RBI monetary policy document states: “…it is decided in consultation with Government that all future investment by FPIs in the debt market in India will be required to be made with a minimum residual maturity of three years. Accordingly, all future investments within the limit for investment in corporate bonds, including the limits vacated when the current investment by an FPI runs off either through sale or redemption, shall be required to be made in corporate bonds with a minimum residual maturity of three years. Furthermore, FPIs will not be allowed to invest incrementally in short maturity liquid/money market mutual fund schemes.” [4]

This is a direct administrative decree that not only transmits confusing signals to market participants but could also incur their displeasure. Rajan even admitted in a recent newspaper interview: “I generally believe we should not micro-manage. But the one place where I do make a strong exception is on financial stability. There are situations when market participants do not fully internalise the consequences of their action because they know they can leave before the consequences hit them.” [5]

One reason for the directive could be swelling short-term loans and the bunching up of repayments in the near future. However, data seems to indicate otherwise: according to external debt data till 30 September 2014, released by the Ministry of Finance, short-term debt is only 18.9% of the total external outstanding debt of about $456 billion. At the end of June, it was slightly higher at 19.6%. [6]

So, why is the RBI imposing this diktat now? Clearly, it is a bit jumpy about the consequences of an interest rate hike by the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank some time this year. When that happens, many global investors are expected to withdraw funds from emerging markets like India and invest in the U.S. instead.

Such an outflow could create pressure on the current account, the rupee exchange rate, and on domestic interest rates. India experienced this in 2013. Rajan wants to bullet-proof the balance-sheet not only before the event, but also prior to the announcement of the Budget at the end of February.


References

[1] Clinch, Matt, Italy launches tax on high-frequency transactions; CNBC, 2 September 2013, <http://www.cnbc.com/id/101002422#>

[2] European Commission, Proposal for a Council Directive implementing enhanced cooperation in the area of financial transaction tax, 14 February 2013, <http://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/resources/documents/taxation/com_2013_71_en.pdf>

[3] Ministry of Finance, Government of India; Revenue Budget, Budget Documents, <http://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2014-15/rec/tr.pdf>

[4] Rajan, Raghuram G, Sixth Bi-Monthly Monetary Policy Statement; 5 February 2015, <http://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/BS_PressReleaseDisplay.aspx?prid=33144>

[5] Sriram R., Bodhisatva Ganguli and Gayatri Nayak, ‘The War on inflation is still not won: RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan’, The Economic Times, 5 February 2015, <http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2015-02-05/news/58838165_1_rbi-governor-raghuram-rajan-urjit-patel-committee-inflation>

[6] External Debt Management Unit, Economic Affairs Department, Ministry of Finance, Government of India, India’s External Debt as at End-September 2014, December 2014, <http://finmin.nic.in/the_ministry/dept_eco_affairs/economic_div/ExternalDebt_Sep14_E.pdf>


© Copyright 2014 Gateway House: Indian Council on Global Relations. All rights reserved. Any unauthorized copying or reproduction is strictly prohibited.

Reprinted with permission from Gateway House: http://www.gatewayhouse.in/a-tobin-tax-for-india/
and
The Hindu BusinessLine: http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/tobin-tax-makes-a-lot-of-sense/article6898724.ece?homepage=true

Sunday, 28 March 2010

Too Many Wise Men?

How many men does it take to run the economy? Numerous, going by the number of experts voicing their opinion in Delhi.

The multiple lines of economic command have been visible for some time now. If there were ever any doubts, one had to only tune into the babble of eco-speak emanating from Delhi soon after the wholesale price index numbers for February were announced. There was understandable panic because the inflation rate was nudging the treacherous double-digit mark. But, going by the comments made, it would seem that there were many more people out there in Delhi who knew what the Reserve Bank should be doing and when it should be timing its next action. And, then came the unexpected RBI rate hike to quell some of the inflationary flames. But, instead of diminishing, the decibel level actually went up by a few notches with the experts now holding forth that RBI needed to implement another rate hike.

But, what has been described above is only a symptom of a larger trend in economic policy management. Over the past few years, the number of ecocrats has multiplied and with it have the number the divergent views and conflicting opinions. All this is, of course, great grist for the electronic media.

Here’s a look at the chief policy manager and the various people in the economic management team.

· Prime minister Manmohan Singh: An established economist with pucca Oxbridge cred. Gained respect worldwide for having pulled the Indian economy back from the brink of bankruptcy and then steering it out of the stifling, controlled regime to a new liberal and competitive framework.
· C Rangarajan: Another well regarded economist. The former RBI governor is currently the Chairman of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Committee. Obviously, knows his monetary onions well and makes them public as well.
· Montek Singh Ahluwalia: Another Oxbridge-World Bank alum who gained fame as an economic advisor during Rajiv Gandhi’s time. Was Chief Economic Advisor in finance ministry when Manmohan Singh was finance minister. Is currently Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission. A favourite with the sound-bite hunters on all topics – from the state of the monsoons to the interest rate structure.
· Kaushik Basu: A vociferous champion of free economy, this former don – he taught at Delhi School of Economics and Cornell University – has been recently appointed as Chief Economic Advisor to the finance minister. He is the hunting pack's new quarry.
· Pronab Sen: Chief Statistician, Sen is currently trying to overhaul the way data is collected, tossed and diced, and then the manner in which the decision-making apparatus interprets it. He has also been vocal with his views on inflation and interest rates.
· Raghuram Rajan: Occupant of tenured chair at University of Chicago and a former Chief Economist at IMF, this man has been quietly advising the PM on a number of issues, including financial sector reforms. The super regulator proposed in Budget 2010 – which is expected to supercede all the other financial sector regulators in the country, such as RBI, SEBI, IRDA -- was suggested by the panel headed by him.
· Pranab Mukherjee: The man who, as finance minister, is in the thick of it but does not speak much at all, except to voice the government’s overall concern from time to time over inflation, interest rates and their impact on credit growth and the general well-being in the economy.
· D Subbarao: Governor at RBI, who played an impressive role in launching the fire-fighting operations in close coordination with the fiscal authorities soon after Lehman Brothers went belly up. He is also trying to improve some of RBI’s traditional ways (such as, communication), but unfortunately that is seen as a weakness and he is considered fair game by everyone in Delhi. So, almost every ecocrat has a word of advice for him.

There is nothing wrong in having such a large and high-calibre team of economists in charge of policy management. But, policy direction starts sounding out of whack when all of them speak in different and contradictory tongues.